top of page

BRIGADIER FREE INDIA -By Lt Col Noel Ellis

Writer: Lt Col Noel Ellis
Lt Col Noel Ellis
3 hours ago
5 min read

Editor's Note:The atmosphere in the country has become quite serious ,especially where military matters are concerned ,resulting in endless debates and controversies about the manner in which military affairs/ matters are being handled/ dealt with not only by the political masters and bureaucrats but more importantly by our own military hierachy which does not / cannot voice its views openly or protest about Govt decisions. 


This piece by Lt Col Noel Ellis breaks the seriousness of the debates on some of the ongoing issues that are now in the media / social media . Noel has that rare military humour that he articulates so aptly and crisply that he conveys what he wants with some rare and popular military humour that is easily grasped by military readers.  


- Editor MVI

I was keenly reading and listening to views on the Agnipath Scheme over the past few days when, up the “grapevine” came another interesting topic: the abolition of the Brigadier and equivalent ranks from the Armed Forces.



Then came an article in the newspaper which spread like wildfire, at least in the veterans’ circle, with views and counterviews. I have a different take on both. So, read on…


My views on the Agniveer Scheme were very clear from day one, and I still stand by them. It was too much of bureaucratic and political connivance that was forced down the gullet of the Armed Forces. This was opposed tooth and nail by the veterans and, by the serving fraternity, only in subdued voices, for obvious reasons.



Little did the government realise that we would have to undertake ‘OP Sindoor’. Every man jack was needed. Every gun had to fire. Every drone needed an operator, and that’s how we put the enemy in his place. This time, it was the man behind the gun, the drone, the aircraft or the remote control.


Perhaps some realisation would have dawned in the highest echelons of the government that retaining just 25% was a folly. I am sure the Service Chiefs would have played their cards right by now.


How does the ‘government’ wipe the egg smeared on its face? Agniveers were needed, and desperately so, more than ever. Isn’t it?



“Chalo, kuch sudhaar karte hain.” Mind you, not “hair-fair”! This must have been the thought to save face. For lack of manpower, China to chhoro, Pakistan ne thok diya phir! Then the cliché, “Jo theek samjho, woh karo,” must have been uttered.


I can imagine the negotiations between the Armed Forces, who would have definitely pitched for at least 80% retention. Then the RM would have intervened and spoken to our CDS: “Yaar, kuch toh izzat rakh lo. 75% mein maan jao na.” I am just conjecturing!


Like a magnanimous CDS, he would have said, “Aye aye, Sir!” Rather, “Wilco”, being from the Army.


In the meantime, the Babus must have been put to task by the RM: “Ki koi ghundi lagao, jis se saanp bhi mar jaye aur lathi bhi na toote.” Thus, new terms and conditions for the freshers, the absorbed and the retained must have evolved.



“Divide and rule” can be seen at its best by complicating the whole issue. The Armed Forces must have breathed a sigh of relief. For them, “bhagte chor ki langoti hi sahi.” The veterans too calmed down after their relentless criticism. A win-win situation for all!


Who was made the scapegoat? No bureaucrat, no RRM or RM came to the fore. The poor CDS bore the brunt, much like the Adjutant General had to do four years ago. Nevertheless, “der aaye, durust aaye.” Two years isn’t long. It will pass in a jiffy.


One thing I was always sceptical about was the fate of the “throwaway” Agniveers. The state governments and corporates were willing to absorb these well-trained people. “Fauj train kare, goli khaye, fir nikale jayen aur baaki sab unko absorb kar le. Hum ko mile Baba ji ka thullu!”



Realisation dawned, and some tweaks were made to the scheme. I wish all the old and new Agniveers the very best.


Now, coming to the Brigadier’s rank.


Yaar, Government, aap ko Armed Forces hi mili khilwar karne ke liye? Kabhi dress badal do, kabhi kuch aur. Pehle 2 Lt abolish kar diya, ab Brig ka rank. Wah ji wah!


I would rather suggest that we step it up. Let the starting rank be Captain and equivalent, and do away with the Lieutenant Colonel rank as well. Let a one-star rank on the collar come in 14-15 years. How is the idea?


Young, dynamic, dashing Brigade Commanders! Even younger Commanding Officers and officers moving up the ladder. As it is, we call a Lt Col a Colonel, so be it!


Then it would be from Colonel to Major General, with a few Brigadiers left to command the Bhairav Brigades, just as a few metre-gauge railway lines still run as heritage railways.


I am sure the same Pay Commission can look into it. The finances can be worked out by ‘Nimmo Tai’ and her team, and this time, hopefully, in favour of the Olive Greens, Whites and Blues. Madam, thodi kripa idhar bhi kar do!


There is a dichotomy, though. An officer is taught to take up responsibilities two ranks above his present rank. But the irony is that when an officer retires, he is re-employed many ranks below his substantive rank. A Colonel ends up doing a Staff Captain’s job. It becomes a little humiliating, doesn’t it? A man who could function as a Brigadier is now, honourably demoted, to a rank and responsibilities much lower than what he was accustomed to.

Supersession is part of the pyramidal structure. Who suffers? We all know. Sad but true.


So, let’s have enough Captains. Maybe just one year as a Lieutenant, if this rank cannot be abolished. As it is, they become Barsatis in the field within a year!


Be that as it may, the transformation of the Armed Forces has been happening right before our eyes. Whether it is for the good, the bad or the ugly is a different issue. Pay and pensions apart, the changing nature of warfare is now the order of the day. Due regard must be given to it, lest we compromise national security.


You remove a rank or add one. For example, a Brigadier General could be introduced between a Colonel and a Major General. If we can copy other things from the West, this too can be done!


These were just my random thoughts. You may agree, disagree or remain indifferent. But what I say from the heart has some truth in it. Only if the powers that be, sitting above the Armed Forces, understand this! Kindly stop toying with us. We will become a vote bank one day.

So, let the Agnipath Scheme be abolished and, instead of having a Colonel becoming a Major General directly, we could have an intermediate rank of Brigadier General.


Do you agree?


I wonder!!!!!

Comments


bottom of page